E LAW | Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law - Copyright Policy
Review of "LDL Online: Laying Down the Law: Computer
Assisted Legal Research"
Review of Surendra Dayal "LDL
Online: Laying Down the Law: Computer Assisted Legal Research".
Sydney: Butterworths, 1996 (174 p).
- This book is designed to fill a gap in knowledge of how to use a number
of different PC-based tools and services that enable searches and retrieval
of legislation and case materials. As IT systems are characterised by a
relentless quest for improved technological capabilities of computer systems
and their operating systems, students and practitioners alike need to access
low cost and contemporary introductory materials. This book goes a long
way to meeting such a need.
- A nice touch in this regard was the inclusion of email addresses in
the preface of the book for the reader to contact the author or the editors
of the series Laying down the law. The email address of a discussion group
was also added for those readers who may wish to subscribe to a discussion
group devoted to computer-based legal research tools.
- One of the nice features about the book is that it is well structured
and has a very comprehensive table of contents. While there is also a detailed
index if you may need to locate a specific matter, in this reader’s experience
the table of contents was more than adequate as throughout the book maintained
a tight step-by-step approach to each specific service.
- A consistent format is followed (i.e. what is it, how it works, and
examples) in Chapters 3-9, which deal seriatim with each full text service.
Preceding these chapters, which make up the bulk of the report, are two
introductory chapters, while Chapter 10 outlines the Internet and Chapter
11 deals with AustLII.
- As may be expected Chapter 1 sets out the objectives of the book, defines
key terms and refers to some of the concepts behind PC-based information
systems. Chapter 2 provides a succinct overview of full text searching
with an explanation of fundamental searching commands, strategies in data
searching and a brief description of linking of data and terms by hypertext.
As these introductory chapters dealt superficially with only a few terms
and concepts, a bibliography would have been a useful addition to satisfy
readers who wanted to develop a more comprehensive understanding of some
of this material.
- It would have been helpful if there had been a section in these introductory
chapters about the principles of PC networks. It is the opinion of the
reviewer that an additional such a level of detail would assist users to
better understand the performance of the services covered in subsequent
chapters, as for many it is likely these databases and services will be
accessed through a network rather than as stand alone PCs.
- A number of the text-based systems discussed, Info-One (Chapter 4),
LawPac (Chapter 5) and Lexis/Nexis (Chapter 6) are online data systems
and accordingly have a potential advantage over CD-ROM services of providing
the user which current legal materials. As there are some variations in
the breadth of material that can be found in the these major online data
services, users may need to be familiar with the strengths and limitations
of each. Two of the services, Info-One and LawPac, are confined to Australian
materials, with Info-One providing access to case materials and legislation
for most jurisdictions (except Queensland), whereas LawPac largely contains
case law for all jurisdictions except Western Australia.
- As the Lexis/Nexis system is based in the United States, as may be
expected this service provides a very broad coverage of American federal
and state case law, statutes, regulations and public records. Lexis/Nexis
also provides access to legal services from Canada, a number of other European
jurisdictions, Australia and New Zealand and enables the user to access
a broader spectrum of business and other relevant information from these
jurisdictions.
- The book provides a sense of the capabilities of each service by outlining
details of the special features of each system. This is supplemented by
examples of data searches and short exercises for the reader to undertake
as a form of review at the end of each chapter. A strength of each chapter
was the frequent inclusion of screen shots to assist the reader visualise
the different steps involved in considering a topic, refining a search
by use of keywords and parameters and steps in downloading or printing
results.
- At the time the book was being written a number of CD-ROM services
were in the final stages of development with release planned during 1996.
These services are Butterworths Research library, and LBC’s The complete
legal research system. As both of these services utilise the same software
application, FolioViews, the author provides a separate step-by-step overview
of the use of this software in Chapter 7, before discussing each service
separately in Chapters 8 and 9.
- Many of the services provided through these two CD-ROM services will
already be familiar to many. The Butterworths CD-ROM contains Halsbury’s
laws of Australia, Australian current law, Australian legal words and phrases,
as well as some additional services containing annotated Federal legislation,
with planned additional annotations for a number of jurisdictions in the
near future. LBC’s CD-ROM contains the laws of Australia, Australian digest,
Australian legal monthly digest and Australian case citator.
- There are important differences in the nature of the material contained
on these CD-ROMs compared to the earlier online case materials. The implications
of this difference is thoroughly dealt with by the author through a helpful
discussion in the book about the way information is searched and indexed
by the FolioViews application.
- As in these CD-ROMs each paragraph within the selected database is
treated as a record, a paragraph can be understood as being equivalent
to an individual document. This means that results of a search will be
a function of the matches made within each individual document. This may
be contrasted with the full text system that underpins Info-one, LawPac
and Lexis/Nexis. In these systems an individual document is understood
as a case or a statute and accordingly a match against your search criteria
will be satisfied if the words appear anywhere in the entire case.
- A useful technique with using FolioViews is to create a shadow file,
as this is used as the basis for building up bookmarks and for making annotations
and notes in relation to a particular search. This means that in subsequent
searches the user can return to this particular portion of a marked text
to either continue the earlier search, or review material that had been
identified before. I felt that the author could have dealt in more detail
with this aspect of FolioViews, as well as provided additional comprehensive
descriptive examples about tagging and downloading records.
- The coverage of the Internet in Chapter 10 is a very good example of
the difficulty in being able to keep up-to-date with areas undergoing rapid
change. For instance, whereas version 1.22 of Netscape Navigator is discussed
by the author in the book, within the space of a year we now have Netscape
Navigator Gold (version 3) on the market. (Navigator also now has a potent
competitor in Microsoft’s Explorer web browser). There are also a number
of useful HTML tools, such as Microsoft Internet Assistant, an add on to
Word 6, to enable a user to overcome the problems caused by loss of formatting
previously experienced when downloading HTML files as plain text. Future
editions of the book would need to deal more thoroughly with these areas.
- I thought there was insufficient coverage of the AustLII (Australasian
Legal Information Institute), an Internet service operated by the University
of Technology Sydney. This shortcoming is understandable as it appears
the details of the transfer of the SCALE system (Attorney General's Department
Database) had not been fully worked out when the book was being written.
It is also possible that AustLII is given a lesser emphasis as a system
that may be more extensively used by students, than by some of the proprietary
systems dealt with earlier in the book.
- A good feature of this book is the extensive use of screen shots of
different menus, icons, toolbar buttons and query screens to illustrate
steps in undertaking a search. The book was also easy to read through the
use of an attractive layout, a moderate size font and the frequent use
of emphases and highlights through the text. An irritating feature was
the summary contained at the end of each chapter - this seemed unnecessary
given most chapters were short and the table of contents was very detailed.
- The index could have been more helpful. For instance, there was not
an entry for shadow text, nor for Netscape. The text had been proof read
very carefully, which was important in a book such as this which contained
many terms and symbols. An exception to this high standard occurred at
page 152, where the Australian Government Publishing Service (AGPS), was
referred to as the Attorney General’s Publishing Service.
- I recommend this book as a key text and ideal tool for law and legal
studies students. It should adequately equip students, as well as possibly
practitioners, to confidently use the key services and software applications
detailed in the book.
Document
author: Greg Swensen, Student,
Murdoch University School of Law
Document creation: December, 1996
HTML document preparation: Brett
Lester, Assistant Technical Editor, E Law
HTML last modified: January 27, 1997 - 08:42 PM
Modified by: Brett Lester,
Assistant Technical Editor, E Law
Authorised by: Archie Zariski,
Technical Editor, E Law
Disclaimer & Copyright Notice ©
1996 Murdoch University
URL: /elaw/issues/v3n4/swensen2.html